Simon and Matt are Senior Lecturers in Journalism and Media.

In his module, Simon decided to ask students to critically engage with AI generated summaries of theories in their subject area, critiquing or extending the AI summaries as appropriate. Simon has also added a discussion around Generative AI (GenAI) to his seminars, encouraging students to think deeply about how using GenAI might impact their learning.

How have Simon and Matt used GenAI in their practice?

Simon made the decision to use GenAI tools with students in a theory module, one that engages with around a dozen different perspectives in media studies, and aims to familiarise students with key readings in those areas.

As part of the module, Simon and Matt asked students to prompt GenAI to create a 500 word summary of a theoretical area of the module. From there, the student’s task was to provide a critical evaluation or an extension of the summary, with reference to three readings in the module reading list.

“It’s quite an interesting exercise because the [GenAI tool] sometimes generates what looks superficially like quite a good account,” Simon said. “But once you get into the academic literature, we realise it’s quite partial and skewed in certain ways…”

What made them choose to use GenAI?

Some of the reasoning behind using GenAI was to support students in forming a critical perspective on the technology.

Matt and Simon knew that they had a strong foundational knowledge in the subject area that meant they could recognise where GenAI outputs were unhelpful or inaccurate, something students lacked. By asking them to critique a GenAI generated summary with reference to the literature, students were both learning the material for the course and were supported in exploring how and when it’s important to be critical of GenAI outputs.

Simon also mentioned that with the way that digital tools are evolving to include GenAI, he feels that soon we will be using these tools without even knowing it, which makes learning to use them critically and thoughtfully a vital skillset for students’ post-university life. “The genie’s out of the bottle. We’re going to be using this thing or versions of it all the time.”

What was the impact of using GenAI for this activity on their students?

Simon found that students who engaged deeply with the assigned task were starting to gain and articulate insights into the strengths and weaknesses of the GenAI tools they were using, and were reflecting on the limitations of GenAI.

Matt felt that the task “…kind of opens up the AI thing as a text to be interrogated…”, and has seen that students are finding that if they want to substantively learn about the theory they have to engage with the academic literature to take it further.

How have they talked to their students about GenAI?

In seminars, Simon has asked students to compare their work with outputs generated by GenAI, encouraging them to think about the strengths and weaknesses of both. In a discussion activity, he focuses on engaging with students about what skills and knowledge they may lose, or not have the chance to develop, through their use of GenAI tools.

Simon mentioned that he sees it as similar to Wikipedia – that it can function as a starting point, but other sources must be used for triangulation, checking the veracity of what has been generated and evaluating it critically.

Overall, he thinks “…that’s got to be the way forward, is saying how to use it and reference it, rather than don’t do it, don’t do it.”

Author: Bethany Witham

Learning Technologist

SOC Digital Learning Team
School of Social Sciences
Nottingham Trent University