As well as creating a discussion resource around Generative AI (GenAI), Anthony Bloxham – Hourly Paid Lecturer in Psychology – has been addressing critical thinking skills through asking students to evaluate essays generated by Copilot. I talked to him about his research, his resources, and why he sees engagement with GenAI as so important for employability.

Student Attitudes Around GenAI

Anthony has been carrying out research into student attitudes towards the use of GenAI, piloting his survey with Psychology students at Nottingham Trent University (NTU) and then gathering over 500 international respondents. While attitudes obviously vary in such a large cohort, preliminary analysis suggests that the largest group are what Anthony calls ‘Cautious Realists’ – students who are generally on board with GenAI, but show evidence of being more ethically aware and concerned about the inherent problems that need navigating.

With the latest HEPI report indicating that AI use among students is now ‘almost universal’ (Armstrong & Stephenson, 2026), it seemed clear to him that there was value in supporting students to critically engage with GenAI and discuss their ideas around it, in order to help develop skills to navigate the use of GenAI in their studies.

Anthony’s initial findings from the pilot survey at NTU prompted him to develop resources, designed to support students in critical thinking, that he could use in his teaching.

CoPilot in the Classroom

Developing ideas through discussion

As a digital champion for the Psychology department, Anthony attended a workshop around H5P, a tool which supports the creation of interactive digital resources. He felt that this would be a great way to make content that is more engaging for students and might provoke discussion. The simple flip-card prompts he created for students were based around the questions in his research, and offered students the opportunity to articulate and explore their attitudes. Colleagues who used the prompts in their teaching reported to Anthony that they were helpful and adaptable to different contexts, and prompted a lot of thinking and discussion between students.  

Social Sciences colleagues can see more about Anthony’s research, and have a look at the resources he created here:

Helping students understand AI use on their course.

Evaluation with expert oversight

The second step was for students to critically evaluate Copilot (Microsoft’s GenAI tool) generated essays, with support. Psychology essay questions were given as prompts to Copilot, and students were asked to critically evaluate the outputs based on their understanding; they could then compare how they had evaluated the outputs to their lecturer’s expert evaluation. He reported that students found this activity engaging and useful.

…the important thing is you need to use it in a way that supplements, not replaces, your human ability.

Engaging with the GenAI outputs in this way helped to develop student familiarity with the way that GenAI tools can be used, as well as highlighting the areas in which they can provide misinformation or inaccuracies.

Anthony sees the development of GenAI familiarity, critical engagement, and the development of GenAI literacy skills as important employability skills that employers are increasingly asking for as time goes on.

Next Steps

As well as completing his current analysis, Anthony is very interested in collaborating on further research, particularly in the areas where AI intersects with creative outputs.

References

Armstrong, C. and Stephenson, R. (2026). Student Generative AI Survey 2026. Available at https://www.hepi.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/HEPI-Report-199-Gen-AI-Survey-2026.pdf (Accessed 8th April 2026)

Author: Bethany Witham

Learning Technologist

SOC Digital Learning Team
School of Social Sciences
Nottingham Trent University