This year, Rebekah asked her students to do something new: bring in their work-in-progress for the entire cohort to look at and critique before submitting it for assessment. Nearly every student attended the playtesting session Rebekah organised, trying each other’s games out and writing constructive and anonymous feedback for their peers.
This module requires students to submit a playable game about a contemporary critical or social issue. By generating outputs that encourage engagement with digital storytelling, this drives immersive learning and participation in players. Rebekah and her colleagues teach their students about how games can be a valuable way to explore diverse museum narratives, encouraging audiences to engage with both playful and more serious themes. Interactivity and games are key catalysts in enabling museums to engage audiences, making this assessment highly authentic and relevant to contemporary heritage discourse.
Recognising that students working on their games in isolation may be missing out on opportunities to learn from their peers, Rebekah realised that building in a formative peer-feedback point could improve the quality of submissions, as well as building students’ confidence in giving and receiving critique – an essential skill in both academic and professional contexts. That the assessment allows students so much freedom to choose their own topic and game type makes it possible for students to receive such detailed feedback, and from so many peers – the playtesting session wouldn’t be possible to the same extent if students were completing identical assessments.
Facilitating valuable peer feedback
Rebekah described her cohort as “polite” and initially hesitant to critique their peers, which meant that she needed to give particular attention to how she scaffolded the feedback aspect of playtesting. She wanted the experience to be authentic so, after talking to games industry experts elsewhere within NTU, she used a feedback structure informed by the Game User Satisfaction Scale (GUESS) to help decide what criteria students should use to form their judgements. She used a paper form to be completed anonymously, including a mix of tick boxes and free-text responses, with the aim of creating a learning environment where students could feel free to express their thoughts clearly and constructively.
Observing the impact
The session was so successful, there’s no question that it will be included again in the module next year. The atmosphere struck Rebekah as positive and constructive as students were deeply engaged in playing each other’s games, helping shift their focus away from anxieties about how their own work was being received. As well as receiving personalised feedback on their work, students were inspired by playing the other games, taking ideas to improve their own. The student reflections that were submitted for the module made clear how useful students found the playtesting session, even “essential” to the development of their final game.
Building on this success, the module leader is thinking about how to refine the approach based on what she’s learned this year:
- Asking students to upload work-in-progress before the playtesting session could be useful, so students who can’t attend can still receive feedback.
- Scheduling the session earlier in the module to allow more time for revisions before submission.
Rebekah is considering creating a digital route to provide peer feedback for next year, as it would allow her to better monitor the feedback process. However, she has identified some downsides, with the risk that it could influence final marking and take longer, plus the added ethical considerations of being able to access anonymised data.
Where else could it work?
While the concept of playtesting is synonymous with the games industry, its principles – peer review, iterative improvement, and collaborative learning – are applicable across modules and even disciplines. Purchase and Hamer (2018) discuss a wide range of reported benefits of peer review activities like playtesting sessions, as well as the varied approaches to implementing them. Rebekah is now considering implementing similar peer feedback formative sessions on the other modules she teaches that involve production of a digital artefact, such as a short film. She points out that holding a peer formative feedback session earlier in a module could alleviate end-of-term pressure when multiple assessments are due, offering a more balanced workload and better time management.
After talking to Rebekah, we decided to add a question about the possibility for a formative peer feedback session to our ever-evolving Digital Assessment Prompts resource, to structure thinking about opportunities for students to receive formative peer feedback. You can read the Digital Assessment Prompts on the Open Resources section of our blog.
References
Purchase, H., Hamer, J., (2018). Peer-review in practice: eight years of Aropä. Assessment and evaluation in higher education, 43(7), pp.1146–1165. 10.1080/02602938.2018.1435776.
GenAI use statement: I used Copilot to produce some phrasing suggestions based on text I’d already written, some of which I integrated into this draft.

Author: Rosemary Pearce
Learning Development Manager
SOC Digital Learning Team
School of Social Sciences
Nottingham Trent University